How to Choose the Right Potty Training Method for Your Dog

Potty training isn’t one-size-fits-all. Every dog is different—some pick it up in days, while others act like they’ve never heard of grass before. The good news? There are plenty of methods to get your pup on the right track. The key is finding what works best for both of you. 

1. Positive Reinforcement: Reward the Good Sh*t

Dogs love getting rewarded, so why not use that to your advantage? Positive reinforcement means giving treats, praise, or playtime every time your pup does their business in the right spot. This is one of the best potty training methods for dogs and helps build strong habits quickly.

Best for: Most dogs, especially food-motivated pups.

Takes: A few weeks with consistency.

Watch out for: Timing! Reward too late, and they won’t connect the dots.

2. Crate Training: Their Own Little Den

Dogs naturally avoid going potty where they sleep. Crate training taps into that instinct by giving them a cozy space and scheduling regular potty breaks. If you’re wondering about crate training vs potty pads, crates are generally more effective for long-term success.

Best for: Puppies, rescues adjusting to a new home, and dogs who need structure.

Takes: 2-6 weeks, depending on consistency.

Watch out for: Over-crating. Too much time in the crate can lead to accidents and anxiety.

3. Scheduled Breaks: Clockwork Potty Trips

Take your dog out on a strict schedule—same times every day—to build a habit. Add a cue like "Go potty!" so they associate the phrase with doing their business. If you're looking for tips on how to potty train a puppy fast, keeping a schedule is key.

Best for: Dogs who thrive on routine.

Takes: A few weeks to establish consistency.

Watch out for: Sticking to the schedule. If you slip, they might too.

4. Paper & Pee Pads: Indoor Options

If you can’t get your pup outside often enough, pee pads or a designated indoor spot can help. Slowly move the pad toward the door until they learn to go outside.

Best for: Small dogs, apartment living, or extreme weather conditions.

Takes: Varies—some dogs transition quickly, others get attached to pads.

Watch out for: Confusion—your dog might think all rugs are fair game.

Dealing with Potty Training Setbacks

Even with the best methods, accidents happen. Dealing with potty training setbacks means staying patient and reinforcing good habits. If you're struggling with how to stop potty accidents in the house, revisit your routine and adjust accordingly. If you think just because you're hitting the road this weekend you have to forgo all your training, check out these potty training tips for traveling dog parents. 

The dooloop: A Must-Have for Any Method

No matter how you train, there will be accidents. And once your dog does get it right, you’ll be handling a lot of poop on walks. The dooloop makes that part easy—just clip the bag to your leash and keep your hands free. If you're searching for the best dog training accessories for potty training, the dooloop is a game-changer.

So, Which Method is Best?

The one that works for your dog. Some dogs need structure (crate training), others need motivation (treats), and some need a mix of everything. Whatever you choose, be patient, be consistent, and celebrate the wins—even the small ones.

Because let’s be real, the day your dog finally gets it? That’s a reason to party.